Proportional thinking is the ability to compare two things using multiplicative thinking - in other words, the ability to compare two quantities. If this still doesn't ring any bells, think of the word "ratio," which is similarly defined as the relation between two amounts showing the number of times one value is contained within the other. Some examples of proportional thinking/reasoning within the curriculum include: "How many different ways can you cut a sandwich in half?" or "Eric says that 8/8 is greater than 4/4 because there are more pieces. Sylvia says 4/4 is greater because the pieces are bigger. What do you think?"
As mentioned in the fraction unit, teaching with children's literature has become a huge phenomenon within the math world, as there are many math picture books out there that do a great job in providing an introductory explanation about certain math concepts. We were shown a read-aloud of the book "If you Hopped like a Frog" by David M. Shwartz that used proportional thinking and reasoning vocabulary, and demonstrated the idea of comparing two things using multiplicative thinking. Below is a similar read-aloud of the book. Because the unit title "Proportional Thinking" is complex, this would be a great book to introduce the concepts and vocabulary within the unit to future students.
Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBv1NA8jAw0
Additionally, we were given an open-ended problem solving question that asked "How tall is the giant?" followed by a piece of paper with a picture of the size of the giant's hand on it. Below is the picture of the hand that we were given. At first, I thought that there must be more to this question - how can your math question only be, how tall is the giant? But then I realized that for students, they are required to think "comparatively" in order to solve this open-ended question. There is no right answer, however it is neat to see everyone's different thought processes and strategies that are needed to solve a proportional thinking question.
![]() |
| Retrieved from Makkreel (October 24, 2016) |
To give you an idea of how to solve a question like this I will use how my table group solved the question as an example. We started by seeing how many of our hands fit vertically into the giant's hand - which ended up being two of our hands. We then made the conclusion that this meant the giant's hand was twice as big as our own, which would mean that he is twice as big as us. We then used the average height of 5 feet 5 inches, and converted it into centimeters which ended up being 165 centimeters, and we multiplied this amount by 2 (since the giant is "twice" as big). 165 x 2 = 330. We then took 330 and changed it back into feet and inches, which ended up being 10 feet 8 inches. Therefore, we concluded that the giant was 10 feet and 8 inches tall. What was interesting about this question was that everyone solved it differently, but still got around the same answer.
That's all for now! Have a great week.
-Miss Kiss









